Mirza-Sahiba [No Links With Sikh Jatt] [STOP GLORIFYING THEM]

[PunjabiBox]

shika nal kon kar riha relate
Singer ohi gaunde a jo janta nu pasand a .. lok na sunan song shabad gurbani v aunde a oh sun lia karn oh ta koi snda ne
eh ta sabh nu hi pata a ki mirza sahiba pakistan Jat family to belong karde c... oh tym kuj hor c ajj kal v lok karai jande a bhen bhra viya ?? tusi dekheia hi hauna khabra c ..
kise da role model a rehan deo ... singer kehra kise de uh ch paunde kuj .appa v sunde hi a gane koi nasha pata ne kita ajj tak .. eh ta bande de man te depend hunda bhaji

paji jihre gaa rhe ne oh sikh hi ne (bhave anti sikhi kam karde ne ) apni janta sab nu pata 80%punjabi dimag ni use karde ina da haal jine layi gali ose naal chali wala haal aa , ithe lok galata gal jada adopt karde ne, changa geet ni follow karde mada nu hatho hathi lainde ne .....writer singer actor smaaj nu badlan di power rakhde ne but ina nu paisa pyara aa

 

[PunjabiBox]

Bhaji, punjab ch masa e 50 60% sikh hune ne.
Fer krishan te radha nu v band karo
Indian politxal thinking te kehndi aa k punjan sirf hindua da mein kehna ee sarea da
E bhaji folk hunda, kisse hunde ne, ee pure entertainment lai hunde ne te ena da culture de naal goora rishta hunda
Heer ranjha v mulsim ee c hun ona da ki karoye, heer nu hun punjab de culture cho kiven kadd daoge
Waris shah na adtaa jandia ne wala akhaan kitho kadd daoge
I can understand what you are trying to say and you might be theoretically right but not practically
Singer ohi vechde jo vikda
Bhagat singh nu v band kardo one vaal katale c
Eda vaise islaam ch hunda k jehri philosophy ona di philosophy naal mildi nai onu khatam kardo

Bhaji, punjab ch masa e 50 60% sikh hune ne.
Fer krishan te radha nu v band karo
Indian politxal thinking te kehndi aa k punjan sirf hindua da mein kehna ee sarea da (...main sir ji fir keh riah aa tusi indian political mind use kr rhe ho jaanbujh ke isnu communal base te divert kar rhe o eve isnu radha krishan naal attach kar rhe o....)

E bhaji folk hunda, kisse hunde ne, ee pure entertainment lai hunde ne te ena da culture de naal goora rishta hunda (...jihri cheez galat aa ohnu bahar kadna paina ih adat badlni paindi aa apne fayde layi....ik point ton start karage tan hi sara ghar saaf hovega)

Heer ranjha v mulsim ee c hun ona da ki karoye, heer nu hun punjab de culture cho kiven kadd daoge
Waris shah na adtaa jandia ne wala akhaan kitho kadd daoge ((heer ranjh ne iho jiha koi kamm ni kita...adata badlia jaa sakdia ne je will power strong hove bhut expls ne)

I can understand what you are trying to say and you might be theoretically right but not practically (sab posible aa bas strong will power te support chahhida hunda)

Singer ohi vechde jo vikda (main te hamesha kenda iho jihe singera da sab bycott karo jo apne fayde layi galat cheeza vechde......jida kise shraab de thekedaar nu lok smagma ch bula ke smanit nahi karde ise tra ihna singera da vi bycott karo)

Bhagat singh nu v band kardo one vaal katale c (sikhi kesa naal nhi aa sikhi sikh basics naal aa ...aj de parcharkan ne galat kar dita aa sikhi nu kesa naal; attach kar ke )

Eda vaise islaam ch hunda k jehri philosophy ona di philosophy naal mildi nai onu khatam kardo (sanu kise di philospy naal ni matlab koi cheez ohi follow karo kise di jo changi hove ...jo gallat aa ohnu galt kehna sikho naa ki ohnu defend karna )

 

[PunjabiBox]

interesting post...here are my 2 cents.
01. Yes, mirza sahibaan were muslim but they are related to punjabi folk not sikh folk or muslim folk. The reason they are sung in punjab are because the story was published/orignated in punjab. Pakistan has 3 times more punjabi speakers than india punjab. I agree to extant that it is not the best thing you can teach your kids but the truth is there is far worst stories sung in punjabi songs today. I went to attend a wedding in punjab couple of months ago and i was so surprised by the choice of songs dj was playing in a family gathering...everyone was okay with it. We don't do that here in the us...i have made dj change songs during family gathering cause it simply isn't comfortable in a family setting. May be in a club but not at someone's birthday...gosh.
02. Sahibaan was his cousin sister but muslims do marry their cousins. I recently learned so do bhape sikhs (disgusting i know) but ethics my brother are relative to culture.
03. Rest of the points to raised are circumstance based. If a reader is interested in that kind of reading material, how would you keep them engaged. My guess is doing something in the story which no one has ever done (for that time).

I am not here to argue but just say few things...you can't control the world but you have some influence over your own family and friends. If you think you want to make a difference, teach them what's right and wrong, so they can decide even when they see other people doing it or hear it in songs. Singers are in business of making money; not in business of teaching your kids whats right from wrong.

paji main gal ih aa ki asi apna culture bachavage tan hi sada bhala aa ......je ajj asi maan naal kehnde aa ki ih mera father aa, aa meri mother aa tan oh sade culture karke hi aa ....nahi tan angreza nu ih vi ni pata hunda ki kon dad aa te kon mom..............sada culture great aa bas thodia impurities add ho gayia ne ihnu ral mnil ke hi bahar kadd sakde aa ..........aj sare punjabi bachya nu englsih culture hindu culture da pta but apne culture da ni pata kyo........cause galta cheeza market vich ne te sahi naa maape dasde ne bachya nu naa koi source aa ......................so its time to wake up

 

[Mahaj]

Bhaji, punjab ch masa e 50 60% sikh hune ne.
Fer krishan te radha nu v band karo
Indian politxal thinking te kehndi aa k punjan sirf hindua da mein kehna ee sarea da (...main sir ji fir keh riah aa tusi indian political mind use kr rhe ho jaanbujh ke isnu communal base te divert kar rhe o eve isnu radha krishan naal attach kar rhe o....)

E bhaji folk hunda, kisse hunde ne, ee pure entertainment lai hunde ne te ena da culture de naal goora rishta hunda (...jihri cheez galat aa ohnu bahar kadna paina ih adat badlni paindi aa apne fayde layi....ik point ton start karage tan hi sara ghar saaf hovega)

Heer ranjha v mulsim ee c hun ona da ki karoye, heer nu hun punjab de culture cho kiven kadd daoge
Waris shah na adtaa jandia ne wala akhaan kitho kadd daoge ((heer ranjh ne iho jiha koi kamm ni kita...adata badlia jaa sakdia ne je will power strong hove bhut expls ne)

I can understand what you are trying to say and you might be theoretically right but not practically (sab posible aa bas strong will power te support chahhida hunda)

Singer ohi vechde jo vikda (main te hamesha kenda iho jihe singera da sab bycott karo jo apne fayde layi galat cheeza vechde......jida kise shraab de thekedaar nu lok smagma ch bula ke smanit nahi karde ise tra ihna singera da vi bycott karo)

Bhagat singh nu v band kardo one vaal katale c (sikhi kesa naal nhi aa sikhi sikh basics naal aa ...aj de parcharkan ne galat kar dita aa sikhi nu kesa naal; attach kar ke )

Eda vaise islaam ch hunda k jehri philosophy ona di philosophy naal mildi nai onu khatam kardo (sanu kise di philospy naal ni matlab koi cheez ohi follow karo kise di jo changi hove ...jo gallat aa ohnu galt kehna sikho naa ki ohnu defend karna )

Galat Nai aa sir
Nale bhaji keha tusi k o muslim c communal gap mein kar reha ?
J apa tales nu religion den lag paye tan sirf nafrat hi jagni aa hor kuch nai

 

[PunjabiBox]

Galat Nai aa sir
Nale bhaji keha tusi k o muslim c communal gap mein kar reha ?
J apa tales nu religion den lag paye tan sirf nafrat hi jagni aa hor kuch nai

main is point te agree aa sir ji ki tales nu religion base te convert nai karna chahida but mera main point kise khas religion te attack ni aa ise relegion cho hi sai mia meer ji hoye ne jina ne darbar sahib di neeh rakhi .....so we must grab positiveness from someone's culture not negativity

 

[Dalwinder]

ok ok

 

[Singh-a-lion]

Mirja bhaajh bharava marea ....oh loko koi na mirje sang.