Why we need religion ?

[jattpunjabi]

- -
- -



What I am asking is :
Do the Sikh principles appeal to you because you are sure Nanak existed?
What if if one has not History of Nanak to lean on ?
Does Guru Granth becomes irrelevent ?

Thats what I am asking.

Thanks

- -
- -

well BS, regarding other points of ur post i will answer later.....but, it will be really great if u like to tell me .....

.....for a second if i think Guru Nanak Dev Ji never existed then wt shud i do?
.....if thinking same i stop believin in sikhi, wt religion shud i follow nd wy?

thanks

 

[Ramta]

- -
- -

jattpunjabi,

As far as I am concerned I will continue to follow what I follow.
Just as I would continue to believe in gravity even if one proves newton never exist...

The principles enshrined in the Granth would still be relevent for me.

Thanks

 

[jattpunjabi]

- -
- -

jattpunjabi,

As far as I am concerned I will continue to follow what I follow.
Just as I would continue to believe in gravity even if one proves newton never exist...

The principles enshrined in the Granth would still be relevent for me.

Thanks

tu sidhi gal kyu na karda???? jo akna khul ke aakh ate naale aa mere swallan da jawaab nai aa.....mainu ih dass ke je main ih mann v lavan ke sikhi kade hoyi hi nai taan kede dharam nu manna ate kyu? gal nu gol kyu karda....main ohi pushia jo tere dil ch aa.....hai ke nai????

 

[Ramta]

- -
- -

And yes...

Though I would follow the principles enshrined therein in the Guru Granth
I will continue to question some of them...

Especially the one concerning the giving up of the quest of Maya and
the 'mind as negativity' principle of the Guru Granth is something I question


Thanks