Sikh Kaum - Hindu hain yaa Muslim, isaayi ??

[Sadhu]

i think the question should be rephrased to -
Would Sikhism exist if there was no hinduism ?

It's not possble to b a Sikh without being a Hindu.

-

chalo tuhadi gal mann laine aa pher ehde naal ki saabit hunda??

Main sirf eh saabit karna chahunda aan ki final authority on sikhism sadda guru-granth hai,
koi london-toronto based granthi naheen. Here's another snapshot dat may prove smthing...

- -

 

[Dhillon]

guru nanak dev ji da mata v akalpurakh,pita v akalpurakh,bhra v akalpurakh,rishtedaar v akalpurkh.
tu mera pita tu hai mera mata
tu mera bandap tu mera bhrata

Hanji par Akal Purakh kaun hai ?
Loh Granth de panjve Chapter vich likhiya ke Akal Purakh ne Avatar le ke Brihngd Rakshash naal yudh kita.
eh ta hindu matt ni hai ?

 

[Dhillon]

te sabb ton vaddh hindua khilaaf baani kabeer di aa
j ik muslim e kam kar reha ...o sikh hae

te sabh to wadh Hindu pro baani Guru Gobind Singh ji di hai. oh tere mutabik Sikh ni ?

 

[Singh-a-lion]

Hanji par Akal Purakh kaun hai ?
Loh Granth de panjve Chapter vich likhiya ke Akal Purakh ne Avatar le ke Brihngd Rakshash naal yudh kita.
eh ta hindu matt ni hai ?

te sabh to wadh Hindu pro baani Guru Gobind Singh ji di hai. oh tere mutabik Sikh ni ?

Guru granth sahib de according dasso akaal purkh ne kehda roop dharea????
Guru granth di bani daso kehdi pro aaa????

Esse krke conflict chal reha ke hindu pro aa,,,,

Talk according to guru granth will b more easy for me

 

[Mahaj]

te sabh to wadh Hindu pro baani Guru Gobind Singh ji di hai. oh tere mutabik Sikh ni ?

kise jor nu ja keh dai...hindu grantha nu raddh karda ae dasam ..... dasam granth viggre hoe hindua nu sudharda k asal gal aa ehh. ...... 24 de 24 aavtaara da khandan ae.....dasam is anti hindu
mein na pritham gnesh manao

 

[Rickey Gill]

100 gallan di ikk gall, Guru Granth sahib ji di pavitra baani padho saare doubts clear ho jaan ge

 

[Dhillon]

kise jor nu ja keh dai...hindu grantha nu raddh karda ae dasam ..... dasam granth viggre hoe hindua nu sudharda k asal gal aa ehh. ...... 24 de 24 aavtaara da khandan ae.....dasam is anti hindu
mein na pritham gnesh manao

aaho kise pade likhe nu kenda
Guru Ji likhde ke Guruya ne pichle janam vich kise Raaje nu Ved parh ke sunaye is layi Guru Gadhi mili.
Dasam anti hindu pata ni kede paseyo hoya.

Source : bachitar Natak , Dasam Granth

 

[Dhillon]

Guru granth sahib de according dasso akaal purkh ne kehda roop dharea????
Guru granth di bani daso kehdi pro aaa????

Esse krke conflict chal reha ke hindu pro aa,,,,

Talk according to guru granth will b more easy for me

jihna granth vicho Ardaas layi gayi, uhna di gall ta karni hi peeni.

 

[bapu da laadla]

jihna granth vicho Ardaas layi gayi, uhna di gall ta karni hi peeni.

shatri ko poot ho bahman ko naahi
gal ta karni paini.

sade layi eh pankti bahut aa baaki jo marji boli jao.
baar baar iko jahe swaal karke apna te sada time waste na karya karo
kuch nawa topic le k aao es gal baare bahut kuch research kar laya
tuhanu v pta eh gaallan pehla v ho chukkiya aa. pichle thread read karo dobara.

meharbani howegi.

nawa topic shuru karo phe gal karde aa..... sikh dharam caste system nu follow karda eh v ese thread ch likhya c tusi kite ehde te karo magaj kharabi

new topic te charcha karde aa ethe hun khatam karo

 

[Dhillon]

ki topic discuss karna ? casteism ?

 

[Mahaj]

aaho kise pade likhe nu kenda
Guru Ji likhde ke Guruya ne pichle janam vich kise Raaje nu Ved parh ke sunaye is layi Guru Gadhi mili.
Dasam anti hindu pata ni kede paseyo hoya.

Source : bachitar Natak , Dasam Granth

acha...fer te kamm ee barra saukha..ved parr k sunao jao ...seyani gal karea kar koi ....dasam te adi bramhgyaan aa....teri 10 th di text book nai aa

 

[Singh-a-lion]

jihna granth vicho Ardaas layi gayi, uhna di gall ta karni hi peeni.

Simply means jehde granth cho sanu gyaan sojhi mildi ohnu paase rakh dayie,,

Guru granth de according ardass kr lao ki fark penda,,,
Mangna taan munda,,kothi,,,car,,,cash hi hunda

Hun keerat poet vargi ardass taan krda ni koi

 

[Dhillon]

acha...fer te kamm ee barra saukha..ved parr k sunao jao ...seyani gal karea kar koi ....dasam te adi bramhgyaan aa....teri 10 th di text book nai aa

Dasam vich likhiya main apne kolo ta bana ni reha,
'kabeer' anti hindu si is layi 'Sikh' si, idha di siyani gall kareya kara

 

[Singh-a-lion]

Dasam vich likhiya main apne kolo ta bana ni reha,
'kabeer' anti hindu si is layi 'Sikh' si, idha di siyani gall kareya kara

Jado bharm ji sojhi aa jandi,,te oss bande dia galla anti laggan lag jandia coz ohnu pata hunda pathran nu matha tekan pani paun,,dhagge banan naal kuch ni hunda,,te jehde lok edan krde oh khende eh taan anti bolda,,,but oh apne vallo ik ik gal sach keh reha hunda


For example. Guru gobind singh ji di bani di jinni ku knwlegde meinu aa ohde according je ahh lines kisse agyaani bande nu padha dayie ohne kehna sikha da guru wala anti aa sade

ਕਾਹੂ ਲੈ ਪਾਹਨ ਪੂਜ ਧਰਯੋ ਸਿਰ ਕਾਹੂ ਲੈ ਲਿੰਗ ਗਰੇ ਲਟਕਾਇਓ ॥
Someone worshipped stone and placed it on his head. Someone hung the phallus (lingam) from his neck.

ਕਾਹੂ ਲਖਿਓ ਹਰਿ ਅਵਾਚੀ ਦਿਸਾ ਮਹਿ ਕਾਹੂ ਪਛਾਹ ਕੋ ਸੀਸੁ ਨਿਵਾਇਓ ॥
Someone visualized God in the South and someone bowed his head towards the West.

ਕੋਉ ਬੁਤਾਨ ਕੋ ਪੂਜਤ ਹੈ ਪਸੁ ਕੋਉ ਮ੍ਰਿਤਾਨ ਕੋ ਪੂਜਨ ਧਾਇਓ ॥
Some fool worships the idols and someone goes to worship the dead.


ਕੂਰ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਉਰਝਿਓ ਸਭ ਹੀ ਜਗ ਸ੍ਰੀ ਭਗਵਾਨ ਕੋ ਭੇਦੁ ਨ ਪਾਇਓ ॥੧੦॥੩੦॥
The whole world is entangled in false rituals and has not known the secret of Lord-God

 

[Dhillon]

Jado bharm ji sojhi aa jandi,,te oss bande dia galla anti laggan lag jandia coz ohnu pata hunda pathran nu matha tekan pani paun,,dhagge banan naal kuch ni hunda,,te jehde lok edan krde oh khende eh taan anti bolda,,,but oh apne vallo ik ik gal sach keh reha hunda

Dhanne jatt de pathar pooj ke hi bharm sojhi hoye. SGGS vich hi likhiya,

Our Guru were not anti hindu or anti any religion.
sggs vich ta narayan poojan wale Namdev di baani bhi darj hai te kabeer di bhi.

Baba Nanak te Mecca bhi gaya ta Hardwaar bhi, hunn koi keh reha ke je Sikh mandir chala jaye te oh Sikh ni renda.

How come the most modern religion is the least liberal of all ?

 

[Mahaj]

Dasam vich likhiya main apne kolo ta bana ni reha,
'kabeer' anti hindu si is layi 'Sikh' si, idha di siyani gall kareya kara

kabeer anti hindu c..atte sikh c.... ....Iss layi tu kolon laa reha....parr upper jaa k

 

[Singh-a-lion]

Dhanne jatt de pathar pooj ke hi bharm sojhi hoye. SGGS vich hi likhiya,

Our Guru were not anti hindu or anti any religion.
sggs vich ta narayan poojan wale Namdev di baani bhi darj hai te kabeer di bhi.

Baba Nanak te Mecca bhi gaya ta Hardwaar bhi, hunn koi keh reha ke je Sikh mandir chala jaye te oh Sikh ni renda.

How come the most modern religion is the least liberal of all ?

True ,,our gurus were nt anti hindu ,,dey wer just anti pakhand, according to sikh je mein pakhand dasan lag pea taan ethe ladai ho jani,,soo smjhdaar bande samjh jaan ke sikh layi pakhand ki aa,,

Mein parso mandir cha ja k ayea ik dost de viah te,, uthe pandit ji tilak launde c,mein nai lavayea,, pandit ji ne muh taan vatea,,par mein aun lagga pandit ji nu ik gal jaroor keh ayea,,mein keha pandit ji naraj hon wali gal nai aa,,je tusi kade gurughar aye taan asi tuhanu thakke naal sri saab ni pavoni,, oh smjh gaya te hass pea,,

Hun mandir jaan naal mein sikh da sikh hi reha,,hindu nai banea,,

Narayan di viakhea bare jaankaari chaidi taan panjve pathsah di bani pado,,,kamaal da explain kita narayan nu.

 

[DBF]

eh article mukda nae 8. Are Sikhs Hindus?

 

[Dhillon]

yes they were against pakhand and superstition.

lol, mandir jake tu hindu ni baneya par tilak la ke Hindu ban jana si

picture from Gurudwara Gobinwal Sahib,
Baba Buddha ji applying tilak on the forehead of Guru Ramdas Ji.

 

[Singh-a-lion]

yes they were against pakhand and superstition.

lol, mandir jake tu hindu ni baneya par tilak la ke Hindu ban jana si

picture from Gurudwara Gobinwal Sahib,
Baba Buddha ji applying tilak on the forehead of Guru Ramdas Ji.

Gurnanak di sikhi khendi thakke naal janeu pauna ni te thakke naal kisse da lehn ni dena.

Pictures taan bahut aa edan diya k banon wale ne gur nanak de rakhdi v ban ti
Bebe nanki ji toon lol

Je koi guru granth cha jaankari aa tilak bare taan pangti post kr deo. Jaroor vichaara ge.