Migrant workers in Punjab

Kul meri ghar dean naal gul hoi....

tey mehnu pata lagea ki ludhianey ch curfew lagea hoea....jad meh puchea kyun tah pata lagea.....dujey state to aey workers ney shanti bhang karan di koshish kiti.

Pehla ehna ney police walea tey hamla kita.....ohna toh kut khaadi tey fir bandey ikhathey karkey jad trains tey caran nu agg laun lagey tah lagey dey pind walean ney kutey.

Meh eh puchna chauna tuhanu ki lagda state ch ashanti falaun ch...

Kina k role badal da?

Kina k role religion da?

Kina k role system ch corruption da jah unsuccessful system da?

tey Ki Punjab nu dujea states wang eh rule lagu nahi karna chahida ki migrant workers ehthey zameen na bana sakan ...tey sirf aun kam karan tey apni state wapas jaan?

Jeh han tah eh rule kisdey karkey nahi ban reha?

Hamesha Badal shanti di appeal karda hey tey kadi isney law and order maintain karan lai pehla kadam chukea?

Ki eh hamesha har ik mudey tey politics nahi khed da?

Ki migrant workers nu dangey karney chahidey ney?

Asin horna nu tah terrorist keh dihney a ...ki eh public property da nuksaan karan waley tey trains cho bandey kad key kutan waley is category ch aundey hun?

Pichey jahey jad Austria ch baba marea tah Punjab ch ashanti falaun da ki matlab c???

Jad Punjab ch migrant workers di ginti majority naalo wadh gai tah ehda matlab a eh maari moti gul tey dangey karan tey utar aun gey??

Tey us time tan leader v ehna dey hon gey???

.....

Eh gallan sochan walian ney.......kyunki es barey saadey leader nahi soch rahey......oh tah har ik mudey tey politics khed rahey ney.


Kyun nahi har ik di entry kiti jandi jad oh state ch aunda.....just to kep track and kyun votan lain dey naam tey migrants dey nakli voter cardds ban rahey ney jad ki oh eligible v ni haigey
 

Dhillon

Dhillon Sa'aB™
Staff member
adha punjab aap bahr de mulka ch dihadi karda, fer tu idha diya gallan karda.

je canada ch koi punjabi sara din dihadi karre, shaam nu nashedi habshi ohde paise kho len.
police kuch na karre, oh bhukhe marde danga hi karu.

je canada/uk/us ne punjabiya nu jameen len to rok ditta ? fer :p
 
^^ tey 22 jehrey dujian states waley rokdey a india ch?????

Ohna barey v koi vichaar deo.....key apan Punjab naal hi dhakey dey hak ch an??? :wacko



P.S - Ho sakey tah baki questions tey v nazar mar leo.
 

SHauKeeN GaBRu

Chardi Kala
If Punjab govt wants to be like a Gulf state, thn thy should go ahead and not allow non-punjabis to make property...but y should they do tht?? If punjabis can go abroad, make money/property, thn y cant migrant Indian workers do the same in Punjab??
Otherwise, punjabi's shouldn't go abroad, do whtever thy can do the best in Punjab :nerd
But I believe, its the corruption that pulls back the state
 
adha punjab aap bahr de mulka ch dihadi karda, fer tu idha diya gallan karda.

je canada ch koi punjabi sara din dihadi karre, shaam nu nashedi habshi ohde paise kho len.
police kuch na karre, oh bhukhe marde danga hi karu.

je canada/uk/us ne punjabiya nu jameen len to rok ditta ? fer :p


Ehda matlab tuhadey mutabik dangey karney ohna dey zaiz a????

tey jad saadey bandey karan dangey tah terrorist a gey..rofl

Legal recourse naa di koi cheez hundi a jiddah har waar punjab dey bandea nu keha janda.


1. Es gall da meh ki matlab kadan ki Punjab apni economy dujea lai open rakhey par jad ehi gul koi himachal nu kehnda tah oh kehndey a non himachalis saadi state ch land nai khareed sakdey. Eh tah fir ohi gul hoi America ap bhavey environment dian dhajian ura reha hovey tey india nu keh reha apnia factories cho carbom emissions ghat karo......:rolleyes:


2. Tey Canadian government track rakhdi a .......country dey immigration levels tey. Tah ki immigrants dey aun da country tey effect monitor kita ja sakey. In other words immigration tah hi allow kiti a kyunki ohna di country tey positive effect hunda....na ki loki ehhtey a key dangey kardey a.......:rolleyes:.....tey isto pehla ki koi kahvey ki migrant workers dey sir tey hi punjab chalda......tah meh kehna ehda matlab eh ni oh peacful citizens nu trains cho kad kad key kutan:wacko

3. Tey teeji gul.......sarean nu pata state ch crime kis karkey vadhea.....police system ch corruptness karan tey migrant workers karan. Kyun ni saadi state track rakh sakdi kaun aunda state ch tey kaun janda??????? jeh ehdey naal crime prevention hovey??????
Sab toh jadey ghar ch chorian tey bandey maran dey incidents ch pata kaun involved hunda......:rolleyes:


P.S - Jah tah har ik state ch same rule lagu honey chahidey a tey jah fir state nu apney rule ap banaun deo.........Eh kehri gul hoi ki Punjab ch jehra marji a key zameen khareed lawey tey jeh meh jawan duji state ch meh kuch ni lai sakda kyunki meh Punjab da born an.....:wa


tey naaley baki questions tey v nazar mar leo ....regarding saadi leadership....jehri mari hoi a.


Think about it. Equal opportunity for everyone is not much to ask for. :nerd
 
you can buy,sell,mortgage property in himachal.

if i may add.......with so many restrictions that its made a tougher than required process for other people(non himachalis) to own land.

why cant punjab do the same??? why are you people so outraged when Punjab does it?????????

Now before you say maharashtra has these 2.

"an interesting (discussion).himachal pradesh. has restrictions,maharashtra has these too.
what about all the himachalis settled in the punjab with ALL the rights !it seems to be that the punjab is the only state in india where any tom,dick or harry can come in and has instantly all the rights!!!!!"


You got any good points to refute why Punjab should not put up the same restrictions as himachal to protect the interest of its local population??????? :pop
 

Dhillon

Dhillon Sa'aB™
Staff member
When himachal was formed it was the poorest state in india ( still not much better )
no industrial infrastructure or much agriculture to speak of. people were literally dying.they would have sold their properties for dirt cheap to outsiders so the law was formed to protect them ( wont go in much detail abt how... )

it was a good and necessary law for the time.

And why punjab should not allow outside investment ? i am not getting your point.
 

onlycheema

Banned
Compare this to your own diaspora going into other countries and prospering, how are they doing anything different here, maybe we are feeling the heat, but don't let emotions cast curtains on your mind. Take australia, they demonstrated and all, and i know half of guys don't even take tickets of sydney local, not just sydney locals, we in general never obey simple enough rules. So if we are allowed to buy property outside our country, our countrymen shouldn't be discriminated. You will perceive the world as bad as want to portray it, you go out with a hammer in hand everything will look nails to you. Easy, start viewing world as a nice place and not something conspiring against you somehow.
 
These states with the so called "restrictions" still allow investments from outside companies i.e businesses or individuals that want to start investment without any restrictions.........but they have made it difficult for people from other states to buy permanent housings in their states.

It's like they are saying if you want to come here.......finish your work and head back home.......right???

Do the work for our state but dont live here ??????

Now my point is why cant punjab do the same????? ........Why is there so much outrage when by doing this we are protecting our local interests just like other states are protecting their??????????

when 100's and thousands of bihari's and himachli's can without any restriction buy anything in our state which puts our local population at a disadvantage.

Punjab born people when they go to other states........run into these restrictions....whereas these people that work in our state have everything:wacko

Himachal maybe poor but Maharashtra certainly isnt.....
 
Compare this to your own diaspora going into other countries and prospering, how are they doing anything different here, maybe we are feeling the heat, but don't let emotions cast curtains on your mind. Take australia, they demonstrated and all, and i know half of guys don't even take tickets of sydney local, not just sydney locals, we in general never obey simple enough rules. So if we are allowed to buy property outside our country, our countrymen shouldn't be discriminated. You will perceive the world as bad as want to portray it, you go out with a hammer in hand everything will look nails to you. Easy, start viewing world as a nice place and not something conspiring against you somehow.



^^Please dont twist my words...............:rolleyes:........I am strictly talking from a economic viewpoint.

I am talking about putting the same restrictions that they have in place not outright denying them their living and better control of who is coming into our state and doing what.

I am giving my own very valid reasons and i am open to change.....your point that we shouldnt do this because a third party might do the same to us does not hide the fact that those people have made rules that may hinder our economic progress.



......you dont have to be a genius to figure out where the law is going wrong especially with regards to equality....
 

Dhillon

Dhillon Sa'aB™
Staff member
@ gabru, now you are arguing just for the sake of it :p

i have punjabi friend running hotel business in hp and there aren't any restrictions in Maharashtra, don't take shiv sena seriously.

And i hardly know any migrant owing land in punjab.
 

prithvi.k

on off on off......
Punjab born people when they go to other states........run into these restrictions....whereas these people that work in our state have everything:wacko

dont throw words without any proper knowledge az it will end up with a laugh.... as urs lines are mostly like putting conflict between communities/peoples
Well go visit south or come to maharashtra check how many punjab born people are settled there.. in south they have huge hotels business own properties who stop them,even some are in politics too ... leave that my own parents are punjab born....first we stayed in goa for 4 years.. then shifted to mumbai my birth place and we are here frm more then 2 decades.. we own flats & properties ,we didn't face any word so called restriction.

....lmao
 
"Every non-Himachali’s case for buying land in Himachal is sent to the cabinet for approval. So real tough to get through. "

Source - HimVani :: Voice of Himachal :: News, Travel, Jobs, Property, People, Culture, Issues, Weather, Citizen journalism & RSS

"Consequent upon coming into force of the Himachal Pradesh tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 (Act of 6 of 1974), the transfer of land to non agriculturists has been barred under Section 118 of Act ibid."

Source - Himachal Pradesh....

P.S - My laptop stopped working so replies might take longer than usual.
 
i got a question about land issues
non punjabis chhado
NRI jaake jo uche uche makan khare karde hai how would u comment on that?
don't you think NRIs need to be restricted rather than migrant workers in punjab :rolleyes:

and yea himachal ch 400 restrictions hai:sleepy 2 generations v ho jan fer v banda himachli ni kehlanda:dn which, i think, is retarded in a way.. they've to go through thousands of siyappe to buy a little piece of land for their houses.
if we have sympathetic feelings about those non himachlis then how can we be that way to migrant workers. They live in punjab, work for punjab and in a way help the economy.. jad punjab de munde kuriyan aap bahar aun nu firde hai, nasheyan to vehl heni ohna nu.. te who is suppose to "take care" of the state anyways:kin and if they're actually working there then why should they be restricted to buy lands there. lol i don't think bhaiye get better jobs in punjab anyways .. most of them do relatively low paid jobs and with the rising cost of real estate , i don't think they can buy major portion of lands in punjab by any chance:rolleyes:

at the same time i feel that other states should also remove the obligations and restrictions to buy lands in their states.

about ludhiana thingi --> how can you only blame bhaiye for sucha situation..police di koi galti ni?the way bhaiye showed their anger towards punjab police was not right but they're not the ones to be solely blamed for watever happened there.. :dead
 
^^^^^I thought we had courts for a reason???

If those bhehie's reaction is justified then i guess you should also vouch for those who are sitting in indian jails for the past 30 years for going against the same police.......:rolleyes:????????

somehow people associate the word terrorism with them even though both used the same violent means. :rolleyes:

Regarding the land issues.....

I don't support NRI's over migrant workers. I am just amazed at the outrage of the people when it is suggested that Punjab can enact the same laws that are in other states.

However.........NRI's do increase the foriegn reserves of India which it so badly needs....without instigating riots.
 
^^^^^i thought we had courts for a reason???


If those bhehie's reaction is justified then i guess you should also vouch for those who are sitting in indian jails for the past 30 years for going against the same police.......:rolleyes:????????


Somehow people associate the word terrorism with them even though both used the same violent means. :rolleyes:

Regarding the land issues.....

I don't support nri's over migrant workers. I am just amazed at the outrage of the people when it is suggested that punjab can enact the same laws that are in other states.

However.........nri's do increase the foriegn reserves of india which it so badly needs....without instigating riots.

i nver said tht bhaiye' s reactions are justified..if and only if you bothered to read my post carefully :)
but lemme quote my post here again

about ludhiana thingi --> how can you only blame bhaiye for sucha situation..police di koi galti ni?the way bhaiye showed their anger towards punjab police was not right but they're not the ones to be solely blamed for watever happened there..

nd about land issues
i would really want to know for what reason you don't support nri's over migrant workers'
 

Dhillon

Dhillon Sa'aB™
Staff member
The law was amended in 2006 but there are still some restriction in buying agriculture land.AFAIK even urban himachalis can't buy land in rural areas.
 

pps309

Prime VIP
i have punjabi friend running hotel business in hp and there aren't any restrictions in Maharashtra, don't take shiv sena seriously.

.
Shiv Sena needs to be taken seriously in Maharastra, even in Mumbai.
Last time, when a Singh was killed by the bodyguard of Jhutha Sauda dera and sikhs protested against it. Shiv sena head Bal Thackery made a derogatory statement against sikhs reminding them of what happened on nov 1984 in Delhi.
after couple of days Sukhbir Badal went to Mumbai to see Shri Bala Saheb Thackrey.
 
Top