Saheedi Divas diya wadaiyaa???

Ki saanu saheedi divas diya wadaiyaa deni chaeedi aa ke nahi?

Pella Pehlu: Aa divas koi Janam Din nahi par Saheed da vichhoda hai. Ess di vadai deni shayad jayaz nahi.

Dusra Pehlu: Saheedi apne aap ch ik bohat baddi achievement aa. Saheed apni kaum diya neeha majbut karke, aan wale samay ch jeet lai raah padra karde aa. Saanu ohna di saheedi nu khushi naal manona chaeeda. Taa karke saheed di saheedi te osnu te sarri kaum nu vadai deni chaeedi aa.

What is your say? Please Poll.

yup deniyan chahidiyan, ohna mahapurkhan ne shaheedi ise karke ditti taan jo kaum, desh..khushali te shantipoorwak jeevan vaiteet kar sake..je asi is gal nu nakarde aa..te asi ohna di shahadat da koi mull ni pa rahe..

its my opinion.

Peace.

achivement jaroor aa but kushi vali te koi gal nai aa.....tragedy aa .....ki keh sakde aa ....vadhai hovve ji thadey guru nu shareyaam taahti taavi te bitha k taseehe de de k buri taraa maar ditta geya c ajj ..bahut bahut vadhean hoon ???
sheehdi deharey jagarti paida karan lai hunde aa kushian manaun lai nai hunde ...
ik roh paida karan lai hunde ...
shadat da mull ...taan shadat nu discuss karkey te kujj gain karkey v paea jaa sakda ...

THE GODFATHER said:

yup deniyan chahidiyan, ohna mahapurkhan ne shaheedi ise karke ditti taan jo kaum, desh..khushali te shantipoorwak jeevan vaiteet kar sake..je asi is gal nu nakarde aa..te asi ohna di shahadat da koi mull ni pa rahe..

its my opinion.

Peace.

Click to expand...

I hold same opinion like yours.

Mahaj said:

achivement jaroor aa but kushi vali te koi gal nai aa.....tragedy aa .....ki keh sakde aa ....vadhai hovve ji thadey guru nu shareyaam taahti taavi te bitha k taseehe de de k buri taraa maar ditta geya c ajj ..bahut bahut vadhean hoon ???
sheehdi deharey jagarti paida karan lai hunde aa kushian manaun lai nai hunde ...
ik roh paida karan lai hunde ...
shadat da mull ...taan shadat nu discuss karkey te kujj gain karkey v paea jaa sakda ...

Click to expand...

I partially agree with you.
Saheedi is not tragedy. Tragedy taa hundi je dhakke naal ohna de naa maaro naa maro kehan to baad ohna nu maar ditta jaave.
Ettho ik din turr ta sab ne jana hai par saheed har koi nahi hunda.

Tragedy
so guru gobind should celebrated assassination of his father ..by saying sarey anadnpur vassian nu teg bhadur di sheedi di lakh lakh vadahai hovve?? .....instead he writes
ਦੋਹਰਾ ॥
DOHRA
ਠੀਕਰਿਫੋਰਿਦਿਲੀਸਿਸਿਰਿਪ੍ਰਭਪੁਰਿਕੀਯਾਪਯਾਨ॥
Breaking the potsherd of his body head of the king of Delhi (Aurangzeb), He left for the abode of the Lord.
ਤੇਗਬਹਾਦਰਸੀਕ੍ਰਿਆਕਰੀਨਕਿਨਹੂੰਆਨ॥੧੫॥
None could perform such a feat as that of Tegh Bahadur.15.
ਤੇਗਬਹਾਦਰਕੇਚਲਤਭਯੋਜਗਤਕੋਸੋਕ॥
The whole world bemoaned the departure of Tegh Bahadur.
ਹੈਹੈਹੈਸਭਜਗਭਯੋਜੈਜੈਜੈਸੁਰਲੋਕਿ॥੧੬॥
Whit the world lamented, the gods hailed his arrival in heavens.16.
--------------------------------
moreover i have read some pharases in jafernamha ...in wch guru doesnt look happy by the sheedhi of shahibzada .....and is talking about intekaam
i can post those verses too
---------------------------------
shaheehdi deahras make us powerful ..they are great source of inspiration but naal naal sanu sawdhaan v karde aa k dubara eda kise naal naa hoe ...!!
sheehdi deharey te ronn da koi matlab nai banda ...but khush hoon da v koi matlab nai banda ....!! sheehda te mann taan jaroor hunda but vahdahean ??...jazba e nai jinda rehna....!
khyaal aa galati da jachak hae